Did the repair queue get shorter or move to the next desk?
· Complexity and Society editorial desk · Worked example and worksheet
The intake team at a fictional tool library ends Friday with three repair forms waiting. Last Friday it had eight. Across town, the partner workshop has fourteen jobs waiting. Which figure belongs in the report to residents?
1. Follow the same job across both desks
Count one open repair job per item. A transfer leaves the intake queue only when the workshop acknowledges receipt, at which point it enters the workshop queue. Pick the same Friday closing time for both teams. Jobs in transit would need a third count. In this exercise every transfer was acknowledged by closing time and no jobs were withdrawn, returned or reopened.
Use the repair-meetup data dictionary if two desks give “completed” different meanings. Here intake completes its part by transferring a job. Residents get the repaired item only after the workshop finishes it.
2. Reconcile each closing count
Closing backlog equals opening backlog plus arrivals minus departures. In the first week, intake opens with eight, receives twenty and transfers twenty, leaving eight. The workshop opens with five, accepts those twenty and finishes eighteen, leaving seven. Together they hold fifteen open jobs at closing.
In the second week the intake team changes its handoff. It opens with eight, receives twenty and transfers twenty-five, leaving three. The workshop opens with seven, accepts twenty-five and again finishes eighteen. It closes with fourteen. Three plus fourteen makes seventeen jobs still open across the partnership. The five-job reduction at intake sits alongside a seven-job rise at the workshop.
3. Write the result each partner can defend
“Intake closed with five fewer jobs” is accurate. “Residents got repairs faster” needs different evidence. Neither count tells you how long an individual waited. Across the two weeks, completed repairs stayed at eighteen per week. Two more arrived than were completed in the second week, which accounts for the rise from fifteen to seventeen.
The Institute for Healthcare Improvement’s guide to measures calls attention to effects an improvement can have elsewhere in a system. The workshop queue serves as a balancing measure here. Two weeks of invented counts illustrate the arithmetic. They cannot establish that the handoff change caused a delay.
4. Choose the missing observation
Have both desks follow the same cohort from receipt to return. Record still-open jobs on the review date so a quick turnaround among completed repairs does not hide older items. If jobs vary sharply in difficulty, compare like jobs and record any changes in staffing.
The two-desk worksheet includes the four reconciled rows and space for another week. If a third desk holds jobs overnight, use the boundary-map exercise to decide who can supply that missing closing count.